First quarter 2020 results : Positive earnings capacity despite an unprecedented market context
Reported net income at €(204)m in 1Q20 impacted by the Coface transaction announcement2 as well as IFRIC 21
Basel 3 fully-loaded CET1 ratio1 at 11.4%, +310bps above regulatory requirements
Quarter marked by mechanical market effects (linked to the COVID-19 context) thus mostly reversible:
- ~€(290)m net revenue impact o/w ~€160m reversible (XvA, seed money in asset management)
- ~(90)bps CET1 ratio impact o/w ~70bps reversible (OCI, PVA, Market and CVA RWA)
A DIVERSIFIED ASSET-LIGHT MODEL DEDICATED TO CLIENTS' NEEDS
UNDERLYING NET REVENUES3 EXCLUDING CVA/DVA AT €1.9BN IN 1Q20 (-3% YOY)
AWM: Resilient results, fee rate and flow dynamics
Strength of our active asset management model with underlying net revenues3 flat YoY in 1Q20 despite some mark-downs on the seed money portfolio. Revenue growth of +9% YoY excluding the seed money contribution i.e. +4pp above expense growth
Average fee rate slightly down to 29bps over the quarter due to a mix effect following the drop in equity markets
Net outflows on LT products limited to ~€(5)bn in North America and ~€(2)bn in Europe (excluding Life Insurance General Accounts)
Outlook: Pursue the development of a truly global and diversified model, building up on key strategic initiatives (e.g. LBPAM) and already successful growth relays (e.g. WCM, Mirova and Thematics) while maintaining good cost management and flexibility in order to adapt to the environment. Good 2Q20 start so far
CIB: Strong revenue diversification together with a tight control on expenses
Supporting clients with more than €9bn financing granted since the beginning of the COVID-19 crisis as at 30/04/204
Underlying net revenues3 impacted by the COVID-19 context in 1Q20, notably across market activities through elevated CVA/DVA effects and mark-downs (Equity dividends). Strong FICT performance with revenues up +46% YoY and from Investment banking/M&A, up +19%. Global finance activity impacted by lower syndication fees in March
Costs under control, down -5% YoY at constant exchange rate in 1Q20
Cost of risk increase in 1Q20 due to higher provisioning, notably across energy exposures
Outlook: Ongoing cost saving efforts to mitigate the combined effect of lower revenues and higher cost of risk. Under severe assumptions, notably including a -9% drop in the 2020 French GDP and a -4% cumulative drop over 2020-2021, cost of risk for the rest of the year could be along the lines of 1Q20 or moderately above
Insurance: Particularly resilient model, driver of growth and profitability
Underlying net revenues3 up +5% YoY in 1Q20 with a limited impact of market volatility
Underlying RoE3 at ~33% in 1Q20
Outlook: Limited impacts from the current environment expected on the 2020 Gross operating income
Payments: Value creation accelerating through the beginning of 2020
Underlying net revenues3 up +9% YoY in 1Q20 of which +13% in January/February
Underlying RoE3 at ~15% in 1Q20
Outlook: 2020 net revenues are expected to continue to exhibit positive momentum vs. 2019
SOLID BALANCE SHEET AND REINFORCED FINANCIAL STRENGTH
Basel 3 FL CET1 ratio1 at 11.4% as at March 31, 2020, vs. 11.3% at 2019 year-end. Ratio +310bps above regulatory requirements which are now established at 8.29%, down -120bps vs. January 1st, 2020. Following this capital requirement reduction, mainly driven by the CRD V article 104 being brought forward, Natixis is now targeting a Basel 3 FL CET1 ratio1 of 10.2% for the 2020-2021 period
Liquidity: LCR ratio >100% as at March 31, 2020 through an efficient joint funding platform together with BPCE. Besides, >70% of assets on balance sheet have a duration < 1 year. This short-term balance sheet should potentially limit IFRS 9 provisioning based on lifetime expected loss
Positive earnings capacity1 of +€60m in 1Q20 despite volatile items impacting the quarter
“Since the beginning of the COVID-19 crisis, our employees have been fully mobilized to support our clients and the real economy. They have been working very efficiently, and we have been able to function in a very satisfactory way, thanks to our early adoption of remote working practices. I pay tribute to the commitment and professionalism of our incredible teams, which has equally been noted by our clients.
Despite the crisis, operating revenues and expenses across our businesses are largely stable compared with last year. In Asset & Wealth Management, strong declines in financial markets reduced our assets under management and led us to mark down our seed money portfolio, but client outflows were limited and the fee rate was close to flat, demonstrating the relevance of our multi-boutique offering to our clients. In Corporate & Investment Banking, we recorded strong results for fixed income, investment banking and M&A, while other businesses were impacted negatively by the environment, including financing and equity derivatives. Insurance and Payments both recorded a solid quarter marked by increased revenue and profit, and the fundamentals of both businesses remain strong even as confinement measures will reduce activity in the short-term.
Our results in the first quarter of 2020 were characterized by the unprecedented environment, which had a significant asset and liability mark-to-market effect under IFRS rules, reversible depending on market evolution and that has a noticeable impact on our accounts. Despite such effect, our earnings capacity remains positive taking into account the exceptional impact stemming from the sale of a ~30% stake in Coface at a pre-crisis price and if we smooth over the year the regulatory taxes and contributions that we pay upfront every first quarter.
Our results demonstrated the robustness of our diversified business model as well as our solid capital and liquidity positions. Natixis' CET1 ratio is well above regulatory requirements and our liquidity is assured through our joint funding platform with BPCE. The measures that have been announced by the ECB also allow us to reduce our CET1 target by 100 basis points to 10.2% for the period 2020-2021. Our excess capital position will be assessed upon this level across the two coming years.
The current COVID-19 crisis is strong and its economic consequences remain uncertain. In such a context, we have decided to push back the announcement of our next strategic plan until the end of 2021. In the meantime, we will continue to focus on creating value for our stakeholders by generating diversified revenues, further reducing our operating expenses and, above all, serving our clients during this period when they most need support and advise.”
François Riahi, Natixis Chief Executive Officer
Figures restated as communicated on April 20, 2020 following the announced disposal of a 29.5% stake in Coface. See page 15 for the reconciliation of the restated figures with the accounting view 1 See note on methodology 2 See page 5 3 Excluding exceptional items. Excluding exceptional items and excluding IFRIC 21 for the Cost income ratio, RoE and RoTE. See note on methodology 4 Management data